It was another memorable Wild Card weekend with two games going to overtime and several officiating observations. Here are four that stuck out to me.
Alternates do more than spectate
Give a gold star to Mark Steinkerchner for saving the crew on that crazy kickoff situation in Texas. Tony Corrente needed some help in sorting out a surprise and Steinkerchner (maybe with the help of Al Riveron in New York) helped Corrente walk through the play.
Experienced crews in the Wild Card round
This weekend featured zero officials working their first on-field playoff assignment. This year’s Wild Card officials had an average of 16 years of experience. Shawn Smith worked his first playoff game as a referee, but he had three playoff assignments as an umpire. Alternates Alan Eck, Ryan Dickson, Mark Stewart and Don Willard each had an alternate assignment, but did not see the field.
This is unusual. If Al Riveron is giving any first-time assignments this post-season, it will be in the divisional round next week.
Overtime ramps up the pressure
Two overtime games this weekend and the crews stepped up to the plate. The sudden-death aspect of overtime in the playoffs pushes the intensity off the charts.
The Cheffers and Corrente crews showed they were worthy of the assignment and kept their composure during the frantic extra frame.
Fan abuse should never be tolerated
Carl Cheffers’ crew was subject to dangerous fan abuse as they left the field. Fans hurled trash at the officials (photo above). Thankfully no official was injured.
I hope Superdome security took a moment to look up at the stands to catch those who threw things at the officials.
And we wonder why there is a shortage of officials…
— Janae Brother (@RestRody) January 5, 2020
Another rule change almost sure to come up this offseason
It is unsportsmanlike conduct for a team to commit two delay of game fouls in order to bleed the clock. In the regular season, the New England Patriots found a loophole around the rule and committed a delay of game foul and a false start foul — allowing the clock to bleed off without the unsportsmanlike conduct foul.
Well, the Titans turned the tables on the Patriots this weekend and did the same thing. To top things off, after the false start the Patriots committed a neutral zone infraction foul, causing another several seconds to bleed off the clock.
It is almost certain that the NFL will change the rules this offseason to either include false starts as part of unsportsmanlike conduct, or a second consecutive foul will force the the clock to start on the snap.
Exciting games are always fun to officiate and I’m sure the crews enjoyed this weekend. Let’s see what the divisional round brings for NFL officiating.
5 thoughts on “4 Wild Card observations, 2019 post-season”
Officials are the face of the rules, and the rules are a MESS. I know plenty of ardent football fans, but not a one who would call themselves a fan of the NFL. In no other sport do you need to consult the rules to say whether a player has caught a ball. The rules say what a player does to give himself up and end a play, but a player who doesn’t do the any of the things indicated can still be ruled to have given himself up. Almost every play hinges on judgement calls, but we don’t use the readily available technology to reduce the inconsistency that this inevitably causes. This is why I keep rooting for another football league to succeed, to give the NFL some competition and make them work for the fans for a change.
How about the inconsistency in OPI? MIN/NO is not according to Riveron, yes according to McAulay/Parry, and then you have a similar flag thrown SEA/PHI
When will Refs be posted for next week?
“How about the inconsistency in OPI”
Al Riveron actually said in response to how that play at the enad of Saints-Vikings was handled: “This is consistent with what we’ve done all year long, we left the ruling on the field. We let it stand.” So he actually admitted what has become increasingly obvious all year, that he is pretty much ignoring (ie defying) the league’s rule on the review of possible pass interference plays. So, the league bosses either need to change the rule back (and just take the heat for blown calls) or move Riveron out for someone who will actually enforce the rules. However, the league would do well to remember that this review rule was put in place due to fan pressure to have more correctly called games, not to protect referee’s egos.
I’m sorry but the refs did a terrible job (especially during ot) in the Texans game. You praise Steinkirchner, but there is a video out (https://www.buffalorumblings.com/2020/1/5/21050351/should-the-bills-have-been-awarded-a-touchdown-on-second-half-kickoff-houston-texans) where he can be heard saying “it’s an illegal forward pass”, check it out! In OT the refs missed; a terrible spot giving Houston a 1st down (wasn’t reviewed), a helmet to helmet hit on Allen, a probable delay of game on the 3rd and 18, and a ‘blind side hit’ where the supposed blind player was chasing the qb, had his hands up to fend off the block and never even hit the ground. Four mistake all made in OT!!
Comments are closed.