Football Zebras
NewsWeek 2 remainders: fumbles become incomplete passes

Week 2 remainders: fumbles become incomplete passes

wpid-screenshot_2014-09-19-14-11-27.png

In the third quarter of Week 2, Jets quarterback Geno Smith was sacked while trying to throw a pass. The ball landed behind him, so the officials ruled it a backward pass with the Packers recovering the loose ball. Also, Chiefs quarterback Alex Smith was sacked, fumbled the ball forward, and the Broncos recovered on a fourth-quarter play. Both were put under a replay review, and both were reversed.

When a quarterback’s arm is going forward in a passing motion, it counts as a forward pass if a defender hits his arm to make it go backward. Rule 8-1-1a states:

If, after intentional forward movement of his hand, contact by an opponent materially affects the passer, causing the ball to go backward, it is a forward pass, regardless of where the ball strikes the ground, a player, an official, or anything else.

In Geno Smith’s case, the only reason the ball went backward was due to the defensive contact. Alex Smith was moving his arm slightly, but in an obvious forward passing motion when viewed on replay. Because the actions of the quarterbacks made the ball a forward pass, both plays were ruled incomplete passes in replay. With the repeal of the Tuck Rule in 2013, the end of a forward motion ends the intention to pass, and not tucking the ball into the body.

The next issue for these plays involves intentional grounding, as it was argued that these passes were nowhere near an intended receiver. However, the rules allow the word intentional to have meaning — the actions of both Smiths were intended to be passes to an eligible receiver, and the intentional grounding rules give similar deference to the quarterback as Rule 8-1-1a does to make it incomplete. In this case, if there is no eligible target in the path of the intended pass, the referee can still call intentional grounding. Such a call is rarely made, though, because it is difficult to actually determine what would have happened without the defensive contact.

Ben Austro
Ben Austro
Ben Austro is the editor and founder of Football Zebras and the author of So You Think You Know Football?: The Armchair Ref's Guide to the Official Rules (on sale now)

Similar Articles

2 thoughts on “Week 2 remainders: fumbles become incomplete passes

  1. WhSomeone please explain, well watching several of Sunday week 3 games. And playother teams plays same hits same holds the ink penalties called. But yet the refs that are working the 49er games are calling on everything for a sneeze 15 yards?
    My second question are these refs being fined for calls that are mistaken or wrong?
    These refs need to have consequences.

  2. 2Tony Gacia

    It is obvious. I’ll tell you how it was.
    The refs were sitting in their SCARIEST REFS HEADQUARTERS. The Headest and Biggest Ref stood and told: “We need to do smth with 49ers and its heaviest fan TG! They can be 19-0! Lets flag them for 15 yards every play!” And the answer was “YYYYYEEEEEEAAAAAAAAHHH!!! SHOW EEEM!! Stuopid Noyners!”. And the Headiest and Biggiest Ref evelly smiles: “BuaHAHAHAHAAAAAAA”. And after that scarriest laugh he cryed: “Bring up wine blood and virgins! Let the party begin!”
    And old poor man sitting near the curvest ever street watching the lightnigs from da east cost said: “Looks its no good for us. There wil be another harbough jump earthquake”.

Comments are closed.

Top