Which new rules were passed: scorecard of the 2018 owners meeting [live updates]

NFL owners are meeting in Orlando to discuss many items for the 2018 season, including 10 rules proposals, 12 bylaws changes, and 4 policy proposals. Football Zebras will be updating this post as information is reported on the status of individual agenda items. A brief summary of each is listed below, indicating the team that proposed it or “CC” for a Competition Committee proposal) and the disposition of each proposal. In order to pass, a proposal needs a ¾-vote of all owners, or 24 voting in the affirmative (abstentions are essentially counted the same as “no” votes; in the unlikely event there are absentees, those teams are not counted at all).

Items that are tabled are deemed to not be passed, unless it is specifically tabled for consideration at the May spring meeting.

Additional information about the owners meeting agenda items appears below the list. 

Playing rules

1. [icon name=”check-circle”] Touchback to the 25 after a kickoff to be a permanent rule, after 2 years of trial (CC) – PASSED
2. [icon name=”check-circle”] Modify catch rule by removing “going to the ground” provision and allowing more ball movement in securing possession (CC) — PASSED, unanimously.
3. [icon name=”check-circle”] Illegal batting by the offense would also be loss of down (and 10 yds) in most cases, consistent with illegal kicking (CC) – PASSED
4. [icon name=”times-circle”] Roughing the passer and defenseless player hits reviewable in replay (LAC) – FAILED
5. [icon name=”times-circle”] All personal fouls reviewable in replay (WAS) – FAILED
6. [icon name=”times-circle”] Maximum 15-yd defensive pass interference, except for intentional acts (NYJ) — WITHDRAWN
7. [icon name=”check-circle”] Allow officiating executives to call for ejections on fouls called by the crew (CC) — PASSED
8. [icon name=”times-circle”] Coach’s challenges must be made within 40 seconds of entering a television break (CC) – FAILED
9. [icon name=”check-circle”] Eliminate extra-point kicks on game-winning touchdowns at the expiration of regulation (CC) – PASSED
10. [icon name=”check-circle”] In overtime with a team trailing by 3, any score counts on a play with a turnover; down runs to completion (CC) – PASSED
11. [icon name=”check-circle”] Lowering head to initiate contact with helmet is a 15 yd foul, can be ejected (ad-hoc by CC) — PASSED, replaces crown hit rule 12-2-8, see below for rule text
    1. [icon name=”minus-circle”] Replay review of targeting — TABLED for May meeting
    2. Enforcement parameters (such as ejections) and mechanics to be discussed with a revised rule likely in May

Bylaws 

1. [icon name=”check-circle”] New procedures for draft prospect testing to be permanent after 1-year trial (CC) — PASSED
2. [icon name=”check-circle”] Reduce restrictions on reacquiring players assigned via waivers (BUF) — PASSED
3. [icon name=”times-circle”] Reduce restrictions of procedural recall waivers for players on Reserve/Retired list (BUF) – FAILED
4. [icon name=”check-circle”] Allow injured reserve players to be traded (DEN) — PASSED but revised to apply only to major injuries, see below
5. [icon name=”check-circle”] Allow non-vested injured reserve players to avoid waivers prior to roster cutdown (MIA) – PASSED
6. [icon name=”check-circle”] Reduce postseason waivers from 10 days to 24 hours (MIN) — PASSED
7. [icon name=”times-circle”] Limit Western teams from playing more than 3 away games earlier than 1 p.m. in their home time zone (SF-AZ-LAC) – FAILED
8. [icon name=”times-circle”] Allow video on coach’s tablets on sideline and in booth (CC) – TABLED
9. [icon name=”check-circle”] Injured reserve players may return after 8 games, not 8 weeks (CC) – PASSED
10. [icon name=”check-circle”] Injury settlements extended from 5 to 7 business days (CC) – PASSED
11. [icon name=”check-circle”] Revise reserve list reinstatement deadlines to close a loophole caused by Thursday night games (CC) – PASSED
12. [icon name=”check-circle”] Revise recall dates from military reserve list to be consistent with the trading deadline (CC) – PASSED

Policies

1. [icon name=”times-circle”] Allow officiating inquiries about specific plays to be shared with opponent in that game (WAS) – FAILED
2. Require permanent female locker facilities in all stadiums by 2021 for home, away, and officiating staffs (SF)
3. [icon name=”times-circle”] Open contract negotiation and signing for a head coach candidate still active in postseason (CC) — TABLED indefintely, won’t be considered in May
4. [icon name=”check-circle”] Relax tampering rules for teams contacting a veteran player who has been publicly announced as cut, but prior to the league’s formal notification (CC) — PASSED, for one year only

Miscellaneous items

1. [icon name=”minus-circle”] Address concerns surrounding National Anthem demonstrations — TABLED, discussions to continue at spring meeting
2. [icon name=”check-circle”] Matching funds allocated for social justice reform projects — PASSED, unanimously
3. Penalizing certain helmet hits other than on defenseless players and by use of the crown of the helmet – point of emphasis that was replaced by Rule Proposal 11, above
4. Rule a player down who surrenders advance, not just by sliding or kneeling – point of emphasis, no vote required
5. [icon name=”minus-circle”] Approval of pending Panthers sale – expected vote at spring meeting in May
6. Approve dissemination to teams of NextGen stats for all games, not just team’s data — vote expected Tuesday
7. NFL Network and NFL Media headquarters to move to L.A. stadium complex — announced by NFL and the Rams
8. Increase debt limit for construction of L.A. stadium complex
9. [icon name=”check-circle”] Approve $1.8 billion Las Vegas stadium plan — PASSED, 31-1.