Football Zebras
NewsSuccess rate of coach’s challenges up slightly

Success rate of coach’s challenges up slightly

Replay statistics through Week 14

Following last year’s spike in replay challenges, NFL head coaches were able to maintain a similar success rate when tossing the red flag through the first 14 weeks of the regular season. At the conclusion of last season, reversals following a coach’s challenge occurred 45.8% of the time. This increase from the 2014 season took place as coaches became acclimated to the strict standard of evidence standard with senior vice president of officiating Dean Blandino as a “second voice” under the hood. At this point in the season, there is a minimal increase of only 3% in won challenges by coaches, and challenges by the replay officials (which are not constrained by loss of timeouts or challenges) are roughly the same rate as in 2015.

More than half of head coaches are at or over 50% in their success rate, even though the current average is just under that mark. Rex Ryan and Doug Pederson share the lead for most coach’s challenges, with 8. Last season, Ron Rivera challenged the most, and although he is near the top of the list for accuracy, he has only challenged 4 times this season. Jaguars coach Gus Bradley and Ryan have had the most reversals with 5.

  Coach     Reversals Challenges Success %
1 Gary Kubiak   DEN 3 3 1.000
  Bill Belichick   NE 1 1 1.000
3 Ron Rivera   CAR 3 4 .750
  Chip Kelly   SF 3 4 .750
5 Gus Bradley   JAX 5 7 .714
6 Todd Bowles   NYJ 4 6 .667
  Dan Quinn   ATL 2 3 .667
  Mike McCoy   SD 2 3 .667
9 Rex Ryan   BUF 5 8 .625
10 Mike McCarthy   GB 3 5 .600
11 Sean Payton   NO 4 7 .571
12 Doug Pederson ¹ PHI 4 8 .500
  Mike Zimmer   MIN 3 6 .500
  John Harbaugh   BAL 2 4 .500
  Chuck Pagano   IND 2 4 .500
  Jack Del Rio   OAK 2 4 .500
17 Ben McAdoo ¹ NYG 1 2 .500
  Dirk Koetter ¹ TB 1 2 .500
Replay booth   NFL 57 148 .385
20 John Fox   CHI 2 6 .333
  Jeff Fisher LA 2 6 .333
  Jason Garrett * DAL 1 3 .333
  Jim Caldwell   DET 1 3 .333
  Andy Reid   KC 1 3 .333
  Mike Tomlin   PIT 1 3 .333
  Mike Mularkey   TEN 1 3 .333
  Jay Gruden   WAS 1 3 .333
28 Hue Jackson   CLE 1 4 .250
  Bill O’Brien   HOU 1 4 .250
  Pete Carroll * SEA 1 4 .250
30 Adam Gase ¹ MIA 0 1 .000
31 Marvin Lewis   CIN 0 2 .000
32 Bruce Arians   AZ 0 3 .000
Coach’s total     63 129 .488

(2015 final replay statistics) Totals including the replay official: 120/277, .433 
¹-First-year head coach, not including interim assignments. *- Playoff team. †-No longer with team. Source: NFL game statistics, regular season only. Does not include Thursday night Week 15 results.

Cameron Filipe
Cameron Filipe

Cam Filipe is a freshman at the University of New Haven, majoring in forensic science. He has been involved in football officiating for five years and currently works as a flag football and soccer official in college. This is his second season covering officiating as a staff writer for Football Zebras.

Top