Senior vice president of officiating Al Riveron released the week 12 officiating video today (video below). In it he covered:Â
Catch/no catch. In a scoring review from the Panthers at Jets game, it was quite controversially determined that tight end Austin Seferian-Jenkins did not maintain control going to the ground. When a receiver is in the act of going to the ground and does not become a runner long enough to ward off contact, he must maintain control through contact with the ground. In this case, Seferian-Jenkins knee hit the ground so the next step is to determine if he maintained control. Riveron claims the replay showed that he lost control of the ball as he made contact with the out-of-bounds line, automatically making the pass incomplete. Hitting the out-of-bounds line is not grounds for an automatic incompletion as long as the receiver maintains control through the act of hitting the ground out of bounds.
4th down/inside 2-minute fumble. Also known, as the “Holy Roller” rule, the fumbling team may only advance a fumble recovery if it is not 4th down or inside 2 minutes of the half. Riveron showed a play which was a legal forward fumble recovery that scored an Eagles touchdown, but described other scenarios where the touchdown wouldn’t be allowed
On 4th down or inside two minutes, the spot of the fumble is treated as the recovery spot, so even if the ball is fumbled at the 2-yard line and is recovered in the end zone, the spot of the recovery is treated as the 2-yard line. As Football Zebras editor-in-chief Ben Austro noted in So You Think You Know Football:
The rules were changed in the next off-season to curb any advantage on such a fluke play in a desperate situation. What continues to be referred to as the Holy Roller Rule to this day restricts the ability of the offense to recover fumbles that occur after the two-minute warning.
The fluke play of course being the fumble in aÂ 1978 Raiders at Chargers game in San Diego when Raiders quarterback Ken Stabler intentionally fumbled the ball forward into the end zone with 10 seconds remaining.
Roughing the passer. A Minnesota defender was flagged for roughing the passer after he made forcible contact with Lions quarterback Matt Stafford at or below the knee area in the Vikings at Lions game on Thanksgiving Day. However, after a quick conference between the officials, the flag was picked up as it was determined that the defender was blocked into the quarterback and though the contact was forcible, there was no foul.Â
Illegal contact. Illegal contact goes away as soon as the quarterback pitches or throws the ball, or muffs the snap and picks it up and throws it. There can still be a foul for defensive holding. In a play in the Vikings at Lions game, Stafford took the snap and pitched it to the running back, who passed it back to Stafford before throwing it downfield. There happened to be defensive holding during the play as a Lions receiver got behind the defense. Since it was holding, the Lions get the 5 yard enforcement and an automatic first down.
First touching. In a punt during the Giants at Redskins game, a Redskins player “first touched” the ball after it hit the ground, and as he scooped it up, he kept running toward and into the end zone. Even though he took possession at the 6-yard line, all momentum is counted into the end zone under the first touch rule, even though he could avoid it. This was ruled a touchback. If he stopped completely or even droped the ball some time after he takes possession at the 6-yard line and before the goal line, the ball is spotted where the “first touch” occurred.